Frequently Asked Questions
Located in its elegantly restored downtown location, the Upper Crust has a sophisticated modern vibe, with a little retro-industrial thrown in for good measure. Playful pops of color abound with many of the building’s original architectural elements reused in new and inventive ways. An open-air kitchen and three exquisite wood-fired ovens invite guests to watch the chefs prepare the seasonal menu with panache. The staff’s singular focus is taking care of the guests — neighbors, friends, family — and creating a place for everyone to eat well and connect. The front area of the 10,000 square foot restaurant, with garage doors that open to York Street in the warmer months, is the main dining area, the back area behind the kitchen and the lovingly restored bar, is the place to relax with casual seating, TV, vintage Skee-Ball, shuffleboard, air hockey, pool tables, foosball, and basketball games.
What are your hours?
Our menu is served: Monday to Friday, from 4 pm to 10 pm, and Saturday & Sunday, from 12 pm to 10 pm
The bar is open: Monday to Friday, from 4 pm to 12 am, and Saturday & Sunday, from 12 pm to 12 am
Can I make a reservation?
No, we do not accept reservations.
Can you accommodate larger parties?
Yes, we can! Parties of eight or more should call in advance to confirm availability. 24-hour notice is preferable, to ensure seating. Please call 717-549-2444 to schedule.
Do you host parties or private events?
Yes, please visit our Private Events page to submit your information, We’d be happy to discuss your event.
Do you offer carryout?
Yes, you can stop by, order online, or phone in your order at 717-549-2444.
Do you deliver?
No, we do not offer delivery.
Do you have entertainment?
Yes! We have TV’s, pool tables, air hockey, vintage Skee-Ball, shuffleboard, foosball, and vintage basketball games.
Are you on Facebook or Instagram?
What forms of payment do you accept?
We accept Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover, the Upper Crust Gettysburg Gift Card, and of course, cash.
What’s on the menu?
Our menu includes our specialty, wood-fired pizzas, as well as appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and desserts. Please check back, as we regularly update our menu.
Do you serve alcohol?
Yes, specialties of the bar include a dynamic menu of original and classic cocktails with seasonal, house-made mixers, a creative wine list, an accessible selection of foreign and domestic labels, and an expert collection of hand-picked craft beers from across the country, with an emphasis on Pennsylvania breweries.
Do you have vegetarian/vegan pizza?
Yes, we do have both vegetarian and vegan options on our menu.
Do you have gluten-free pizza?
We do not currently offer gluten-free pizza dough. We hope to in the future.
What about parking?
There is metered parking right off of York Street, and at the Racehorse Alley parking garage (see map below).
Are you family-friendly?
Yes, we are family-friendly, and have everything you need for your little ones. We don’t offer a separate children’s menu but do include several perennial favorites on our menu such as a plain cheese pizza (The Classic) and a pepperoni pizza. We also have a gaming area, that includes vintage basketball, Skee-Ball, and air hockey games. Adult supervision is requested for children under age 12 in the gaming area.
Are you handicapped accessible?
Yes, we have an entrance that is handicapped accessible, and we have tables that are handicapped accessible.
What is your policy on breastfeeding?
We are 100 % in support of Pennsylvania’s Freedom to Breastfeed Act, where a mother is permitted to breastfeed her child in any location, public or private
Are you hiring?
Walk to the Upper Crust
If you park in the Race Horse Alley garage, it’s a short 5-minute walk to the Upper Crust along the sidewalk that runs between Gallery 30 and the Gettysburg Hotel complex. The garage has 356 parking spaces, including conveniently located handicapped spaces.
19 York Street
Gettysburg, PA 17325
Our Menu is served: Monday to Friday, from 4 pm to 10 pm, and Saturday & Sunday, from 12 pm to 10 pm
The Bar: Monday to Friday, from 4 pm to 12 am, Saturday & Sunday, from 12 pm to 12 am
© 2020 The Upper Crust LLC, 19 York St., Gettysburg, PA 17325 | (717) 549-2444